Here's Jaime Garcia's rookie season:
Here's Jaime Garcia's career numbers:
2010 was Jaime Garcia's worst season according to every contemporary pitching metric and his best season according to the one ubiquitous pitching metric. He's spent the rest of his career so far paying off that debt, and the combination of those two trends is a good way to instill a sense of unfounded dread in basically every baseball-fan demographic there is at the same time.
After all that, it seems like the gods of baseball could have shown at least enough common decency to give him recurring elbow problems.